I wrote about my plan to try flipping a lesson here and am finally getting around to recapping the experience. Overall, it was very positive and I’m definitely interested in flipping an entire algebra unit later this school year. I teach two honors algebra 1 sections, but only flipped my lesson on “Finding X- and Y-intercepts” with one of them.

*Class Section #1:* Students were assigned to watch a 6 minute video I created and posted on youtube. I put the link on my class website and also emailed it to my students. I gave them a notes page to fill in as they watched. The video had 3 examples, and after the second one, I instructed students to stop the video and try the third example on their own, and then watch me solve it after they tried to. However, I forgot to ask if anyone actually did pause and restart the video. Oops. I took Algebrainiac’s advice and gave students an entrance slip to complete as soon as they walked in. It had one problem to solve and asked students to be honest and tell me whether they had actually watched the video or not. I immediately sorted the entrance slips into Correct/Incorrect piles and chose an incorrect one to project and go over on the board.

- Entrance Slip Results: 17/21 students watched (2 forgot, 1 was sick, 1 had a broken laptop). 12/21 nailed the entrance slip. 6 passed it in blank (the four who didn’t watch and two who didn’t get it). 3 made minor calculation/sign errors which made the graph wrong.

Continuation of Lesson: Our periods are 48 minutes in length. After students got settled, completed the entrance slip, and reviewed the entrance slip, about 8-10 minutes had passed. Since the majority of students did well on the entrance slip, I decided to continue with my plan to have students extend the concept to some word problems. We did the first one together (in hopes that some of the students who did not succeed on the entrance slip would start to pick up the concept) and then students worked in groups to complete the other three problems. I made the rounds and targeted the students who did not get the entrance slip right. After about 25 minutes we discussed the problems as a whole class and I gave students an exit slip with two problems on it.

- Exit Slip Results: 15/21 nailed it. The other 6 all made minor calculation/sign errors, but understood the concept.

*Class Section #2:* Students did not have any homework the night before. We started class with me giving the same notes (in person) that the other class had watched online. However, the notes page had a few more examples on it. We did three together, then the students tried a few on their own, and I had student volunteers solve some on the board. After that, students got into groups and worked on some practice problems. At the end of class, I gave students the same exit slip as my other class.

- Exit Slip Results: 11/16 nailed it. The other 5 all made minor calculation/sign errors, but understood the concept.

Reflection: The exit slip results were pretty close in both classes, but I love how with my first class I knew immediately that 12 students completely understood how to do it before class even began and we could use class time to do an activity that I didn’t have time for in my second class. I think I would see better results if the flipping was more consistent, hence my desire to try if for an entire unit. The students seemed to really like it, they said it was really cool and low pressure watching me and taking notes at home. One of my ELL students watched it after school in my classroom when she stayed for extra help on another topic, and I observed her stopping, rewinding, and rewatching. She found it very useful to listen to me repeat things and then have time to look up words in her dictionary.

The only major frustration I have doesn’t even have to do with flipping. I should have been psyched that students in both classes were able to complete the process of calculating an intercept and graphing it after one lesson, but I don’t know what to do about the fact that negative signs and simple arithmetic cause my students to get problems wrong so often. How do standards based graders deal with this? Do you give full credit because the concept is right? And ignore the fact that the student divided 6 by 3 and got 3?

I never give students full credit if the answer is not correct. I currently grade on a 4-point scale, and a “simple” arithmetic mistake would result in either a 3 (a B) or a 3.5 (an A-) for that problem (or standard) depending on how ridiculous their final answer was.

As an example, if a leg of a right triangle ends up longer than its hypotenuse, that’s a 3 at best. It’s a mistake in their answer that a student should recognize, regardless of how it got there. Also, if the objective was something like proper use of the Pythagorean Theorem, the score could be lower still because the mistake so clearly undermines the core of the objective (finding the correct length of a missing side).

Also, this year I am using the 3.5 rather sparingly. I suspect this is connected to the fact that we have a new math curriculum and I am only partially SBG-ing this year. I hope to improve the assessment over the next year or two to where it feels like “real” SBG, which is pretty much where I was at with my previous curriculum.

Thanks so much for the response, Steve! I kind of assumed that it wouldn’t receive full credit on a SBG scale but not having much experience with that I wanted to ask. Will probably have more questions for you in the future about it!

Love this. I think I would have a a much smaller participation rate than you though. I think I will give this a try. Would love to see one of your videos.

Thanks, Anthony! Definitely give it a try. My program has a 1:1 laptop ratio so that definitely helps, however, I think the students need my constant emails with the links to ensure they watch the videos. I’m thinking about making a teacher twitter account so that I can also tweet the links to them.

I use remind101.com to send students and parent text messages. It works pretty well. I recommend it. It’s free too.

Try Sophia.org that’s what I use to house all my video tutorials and I attach a google doc that they have to submit online after they watch the video.